Businesses are already taking AI search visibility seriously. But new research from EMARKETER and Semify suggests there’s one opportunity that deserves more attention: customer reviews.
A July 2026 survey of 75 US SMB search marketing decision makers found that 85% connect online reviews and business listings with their visibility in AI-generated search results. But only 16% say they manage reviews and listings very actively.
That creates an opportunity. While businesses work out how best to measure and improve AI visibility, reviews are something they can strengthen right now.
We know AI is changing how people discover businesses. This research gives us a welcome set of numbers to support the discussion.
Over the past 12 months, 39% of the respondents said they'd seen more meaningful traffic from AI tools such as ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude and Perplexity, while 29% had a customer tell them directly that they found the business through an AI-generated answer.
Alongside this, 76% said it's extremely or very important that their business appears as a citation or recommendation in AI-generated responses, putting AI visibility on a similar footing to organic search visibility.
However, AI discovery isn’t always easy to track using traditional marketing signals. In fact, 31% said they didn't have enough data to understand how customer discovery had changed.
That's where reviews and business listings become particularly useful. If businesses can't always measure AI visibility directly, they can still improve the information customers and AI systems encounter about their business.
Most SMBs aren’t waiting for a clear way to measure AI visibility before taking action. Asked what they'd done to improve their presence in AI-generated search results, respondents pointed to a mix of content, technical and profile optimisation activities:
|
Action taken |
Share of SMBs |
|
Updated website content to be more conversational or question-based |
68.0% |
|
Created structured data or schema markup |
45.3% |
|
Increased social posting |
45.3% |
|
Claimed or optimised business profiles |
42.7% |
Only 9.3% said they had taken no specific steps, while 56% plan to invest further in AI search visibility over the next 12 months.
Measuring ROI from AI visibility was the most-cited search marketing challenge, and only 14.7% said they felt very confident optimising for AI-powered search.
According to Kelsey Voss, Principal Analyst at EMARKETER, waiting for a single accepted AI visibility metric may be the bigger risk. Instead, businesses can monitor the outcomes they already track, such as leads, calls and bookings, and measure whether changes are moving those numbers in the right direction.
Building citations across directories and review sites was selected by just 28% of respondents, making it one of the least common actions reported. Yet those same respondents overwhelmingly recognised the importance of reviews and listings to AI visibility. This is one of the clearest opportunities highlighted by the research.
The research suggests there's still a gap between recognising the importance of reviews and managing them actively:
|
Finding |
Share of SMBs |
|
See reviews and listings as connected to their search visibility, including in AI-generated results |
85.3% |
|
Manage reviews and listings very actively |
16.0% |
|
Manage them somewhat actively |
33.3% |
|
Manage them minimally or not at all |
50.7% |
EMARKETER says AI tools often draw on review content and star ratings when answering customer questions, and that businesses with recent, substantive reviews give those systems more to work with than those with thin or outdated profiles.
This means that for businesses still working out how to measure AI visibility, customer reviews offer a practical place to start. As Kelsey Voss notes, reviews and listings are something an SMB can improve "before it has a developer, a new tool, or a formal AI search plan."
With more than half of SMBs managing reviews and listings only minimally or not at all, the businesses that act now still have an opportunity to differentiate themselves while the competitive picture remains unsettled.
There is no settled playbook for AI search yet, but there’s no need to wait for one. The sensible move is to start with what you can control: establish a baseline, decide who owns reviews and listings, and track what changes over time.
For businesses looking to improve their visibility in AI-generated results, moving from awareness to action may be one of the most valuable steps they can take.
View our AI search visibility tools or book a call to speak to a review expert.